
Should You Take Your House Off the Market for the Holidays?
Once Thanksgiving gets close, a lot of sellers ask me the same thing: should we pull the house off the market and try again in January?
Lesa Miller is a REALTOR® and broker who helps buyers and sellers in Bloomington, Ellettsville, Bedford and the surrounding communities. There's no one right answer here. Here's how I'd think it through.
Why staying on the market can make sense
The buyers who are still looking are usually serious. In my experience, fewer people shop in late November and December. The ones who do often have a reason to move soon. Some are moving here for a new job that starts in January and need a home lined up before then.
You may have less competition. Many sellers take their homes off the market for the holidays. That can leave fewer homes for those serious buyers to choose from, and yours is one of them.
Your home can look its best. A warm house with simple decorations can feel inviting. Keep it light so buyers can still see the rooms.
Why a break can make sense
Showings take work. Keeping the house ready while you cook, travel and host family is a lot. If guests are staying with you, or you'll be gone for two weeks, that matters.
Your listing history shows. Buyers and their agents can usually see how long a home has been listed. A long stretch with no offer can make some buyers wonder why. Taking it off and putting it back on doesn't always erase that history. Ask me how it works for your listing.
Your plans may have changed. If you don't have to move until spring, a short pause can give you time to finish repairs or rest before a fresh push.
If you stay listed
Talk with me about the days and times that work for showings. You can block off holidays and set a window for the rest. Keep decorations simple, keep the walkways clear and the lights on, since it gets dark early now. If the house has been sitting, we look at the price together, based on what buyers are telling us.
If you take a break
Check your listing agreement first, so you know how a pause works and when the listing ends. Then use the time well. Finish the small repairs and plan new photos for when you come back.
So should you keep it listed?
It depends on your timeline, how much you need to move and how much your household can handle right now. It's your decision. I'll lay out what I'm seeing in your market and give you my best advice, and then you decide what fits your family.
Getting ready to show your home this winter? Read Showing Your Home After Dark: What Changes When the Clocks Fall Back Nov 1 and Preparing Your Home for a Winter Listing. Still deciding about timing? See Does Fall Still Work for Sellers in Bloomington and Bedford?
Frequently asked questions
Is it a bad idea to sell a house during the holidays?
Not always. Fewer buyers tend to shop in December, but the ones who do are often serious, and there may be fewer homes for them to choose from. It depends on your timeline and how many showings you can handle.
Should I take my house off the market and relist in January?
It can make sense if you need a break or have repairs to finish. Check your listing agreement first, and know that buyers can often still see a home's listing history after it comes back.
Can I limit showings over the holidays?
Yes. Talk with your agent about blocking off the holidays and setting the days and times that work for your household.
Thinking about selling this winter? Call or text (812) 360-3863, or visit LesaMillerRealEstate.com/Links.
